lunes, 16 de agosto de 2010

Long Live to the King of the Chimps! by Alexis Guevara Henao

University of Caldas


Department of Languages and Literature

Master’s Program in English Didactics

Professor Ospina

Have you ever heard about this story? I guess you have. Once upon a time, in the late 19th century, in a remote, dense jungle in Africa, after his parents’ death, a small child was adopted and raised by a so-far unknown species of apes. More handsome than any other Hollywood star, more athletic than any modern athlete, he became the Brat Pitt and the Hercules among the chimps. Guess who he issssssssssss…… TARZAN! The king of the chimps… However, as fairy-like as it could sound, it is not the most unbelievable thing. Tarzan learned to read English just by looking at some papers left around by his parents, and once he grew up and had his first contact with the civilized world, he learned English and French and spoke them fluently. Can this story possibly be true? I daresay no. This is impossible in the light of some ideas from first and second language acquisition.

Let us take just two examples, real life examples, from children that have gone, at least partly, through a Tarzan-like story. “Wild Peter,” a twelve year old, was found in 1724 in Hanover. He survived by eating plants and acquired animal-like habits. Though he spent 68 years immersed in society after being rescued from the jungle, he only learned how to say two words. The other example, that of Oxana Malaya, comes from Ukraine in 1991. On being neglected by her alcoholic parents, she grew up surrounded by dogs with very little contact with human beings. She picked up dog-like habits and acquired no language. Based on just these two examples, oooooppppp… the image of the handsome, athletic, fluent speaker, Tarzan, suddenly disappears, and one might imagine better a sort of a smooth-skinned, ape-like man yelling and scratching his butt.

Well, the story of Tarzan is fallacious since it is impossible for a person to acquire a language in complete isolation from other human beings. As the previous examples suggest, human contact is important not only for language acquisition but also for the acquisition of those traits and behaviors that distinguish us as humans. But, why is human contact so important? Well, now it is high time to speak a little bit about the LASS (Language Acquisition Support System) as proposed by Bruner. Bruner asserts that, for language acquisition to take place, it is mandatory that there exist interaction, emotionally charged environments that help develop language. But, poor Tarzan! In the middle of nowhere, with no interaction with his own species, with no affection, (though perhaps the chimps might have taken some ticks out of him,) with no input, he would have never managed not even to read the language as the story says, no matter how intelligent he could have been. This also suggests that what is innate in language acquisition is the apparatus, the proper machine, the proper brain, and not language itself; we have the brain, but we have to receive the suitable stimuli to exploit its potential, talking not only about language but also about any other skill or behavior. The LAD Chomsky spoke about is rather debatable now…

The story of Tarzan is also fallacious since it is impossible for a human being to acquire the first tongue, with high degrees of success as he did, after certain age in life. This is what is called the Critical Period Hypothesis, a theory that deals with neuroscience as well since its base is the assumption that the brain loses its elasticity and completes a process of lateralization; after these events, if the person has not acquired the first language, he will be linguistically impaired for the rest of his life. The previous examples, those of Oxana and “Wild Peter,” clearly proved this point. In this fashion, it would have been very likely that, after years of instruction and treatment and exposure to the language (English and French), our jungle hero had only been able to say banana, or perhaps banana-me…

Well, I am too sorry to have turned your handsome, athletic, fluent speaker, Tarzan, into a smooth-skinned, ape-like man yelling and scratching his butt.

Long Live to the King of the Chimps!

Bibliography

Wikipedia. (2010). Criotical period hypothesis. Retrieved July, 2010 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_period_hypothesis

Timothy Mason’s Site. (2010). Retrieved July, 2010 from http://www.timothyjpmason.com/WebPages/LangTeach/Licence/CM/OldLectures/L1_Introduction.htm

Wikipedia. (2010). Retrieved July, 2010 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarzan

No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario